Discuss: Karnataka high court has done a mistake by not allowing to vote five independent and diss

This thread is to discuss the opinion poll topic 'Karnataka high court has done a mistake by not allowing to vote five independent and dissident BJP MLAs'.Independent MLAs have not voted against any whip of their party .BJP MLAs would have voted against their party whip if allowed to vote. These are not against the law. so we have to come to a conclusion that the speaker has voted 16 votes for his party.